If you could see one book turned into the perfect movie–one that would capture everything you love, the characters, the look, the feel, the story–what book would you choose? ~Booking Through Thursday
Donna Tartt's The Secret History has long been in my top ten list of favorite novels. From the opening paragraph:
Except for the murder.
Donna Tartt's The Secret History has long been in my top ten list of favorite novels. From the opening paragraph:
Does such a thing as "the fatal flaw," that shadowy dark crack running down the middle of a life, exist outside literature? I used to think it didn't. Now I think it does. And I think that mine is this: a morbid longing for the picturesque at all costs.the visualization of this novel remains as clear in my mind as the first day I read it 15 years ago. Can you picture this in the film?
Trees creaking with apples, fallen apples red on the grass beneath, the heavy sweet smell of them rotting on the ground and the steady thrumming of wasps around them. Commons clock tower: ivied brick, white spire, spellbound in the hazy distance. The shock of first seeing a birch tree at night, rising up in the dark as cool and slim as a ghost. And the nights, bigger than imagining: black and gusty and enormous, disordered and wild with stars.As far as I'm concerned, the mood that Donna Tartt was able to convey with her writing is beyond memorable. Beyond fantastic. Beyond my imagination. In fact, the more I think about it, the more I realize it doesn't need to be made into a film at all. The images are already emblazoned on my mind. It's a college I've always wished I could have attended, the separate classroom with six Greek scholars and a cup of Mont Blanc pens at one's disposal...
It was with something of a shock that I saw it for the first time - a white room with big north-facing windows, monkish and bare, with scarred oak floors and a ceiling slanted like a garret's. On my first night there, I sat on the bed during the twilight while the walls went slowly from gray to gold to black, listening to a soprano's voice climb dizzily up and down somewhere at the other end of the hall until at last the light was completely gone, and the faraway soprano spiraled on and on in the darkness like some angel of death, and I can't remember the air ever seeming as high and cold and rarefied as it was that night...What a wonderful aura of an academic environment.
Except for the murder.

I remember reading this book a good few years ago & enjoying it. Although don't think I've read anything else by her, which is strange. Am wearing quizzical look ???.
ReplyDeleteI don't think the beauty and depth of the book would translate onto the screen -it would become just another teen campus slasher movie, in all probability. I can imagine Donna Tartt refusing to allow it -she seems a bit of an eccentric from what I've read about her!
ReplyDeleteIt's been so long since I read this one that I can't remember the details well, but I'd go see a movie version of it.
ReplyDeleteThis would make a great movie your right I loved it when I read reminds me must read another by her ,all the best stu
ReplyDeleteI have been wanting to read this one for ages I think the quotes have given me the push I needed.
ReplyDeleteSally.
http://theelifylop.blogspot.com/2011/04/booking-through-thursday-15.html
You've already filmed, directed, and reviewed the movie, Bellezza. The book sounds wonderful!
ReplyDeleteThe Secret History is probably in my top five favorite books of all time. I've read it a total of 3 times and it's the only audio book on my iphone. Yes, I agree the mood, atmosphere...etc.. is perfect. If you like this, I recommend you also read The Magus by John Fowles, similar mood and feel and also one of my favorites. Also try In The Woods by Tana French.
ReplyDeleteParrish, I bought another book (I think the only other book she's written) by Tartt called...momentary lapse in memory. I haven't read it, I hadn't heard very good things about it I don't want her 'reputation' spoiled in my mind as I loved The Secret History so much.
ReplyDeleteBookssnob, I'm sure Donna is a bit of eccentric if I look at the book she wrote. It's so unusual and bizarre, in a good way, at the same time. I think it took quite a mind to conceive of the plot, but also to carry it through so brilliantly.
Bermudaonion, I think it's worth a reread if you can't remember the details well. ;)
Winstonsdad, I hope we won't be disappointed by subsequent reads of hers.
ReplyDeleteSally, I'm glad you are inspired by these quotes; I thought they were quite indicative of Tartt's writing, and I hope you'll like the book as much as I do.
Suko, you're so funny. Film is not my favorite form of communication! At all!
Mrs. B, how delighted I am to hear that you love the book as much as I! I've read it at least three times myself, but I've never listened to it on audio. That would be a good one to dowload to my iPod, though. The mood she creates is definitely one of the things I like best, even better than the plot; how clever you are to know that's what I meant to say. Thanks for recommending The Magus by John Fowles which I'll be sure to look into. I have read In the Woods by Tana French, but I was quite disappointed in that. Perhaps by the lack of resolution?
I know there wasn't a resolution for one of the characters in In The Woods but I thought that kind of added to the whole mood and perfection of the book. What happened to him ultimately had nothing to do with the current murder which was resolved but the book showed how his past affected him for life and I thought it also affected his relationship with the protagonist (forgot their names actually.) Of course, In The Woods is not even close to The Secret History but do try The Magus.
ReplyDeleteGot your comment on my blog. Not sure about Musashi as I've only just started but apparently it's the 'Japanese Gone With the Wind.' However it's hard to get a copy and there's no ebook of it.
ReplyDeletePS The Secret History audio book is great. Be sure to get the one read by Donna Tartt herself!
I'll look for it, for sure!
ReplyDeleteI leap for joy when you mentioned this and I can't in the world of me wonder why no one has turn this into a big screen adaptation??! for crying out loud, this is a perfect book for a movie!!
ReplyDeleteI want to re-read it some day and would like to watch the movie if it ever will be adapted to big screen!
I reread this every couple of years, JoV, so let me know when we should do so together. It makes me happy that you like it as much as I do; some people I've told it about hate it! "You like a novel about a murder?" they say, but I liked it most for the atmosphere she was able to create.
ReplyDeleteGREAT choice! This is one of the most wonderfully atmospheric books I've ever read. I'm game for a re-read one of these days.
ReplyDelete