
Immoveable Feast: A Paris Christmas
Author: John Baxter
Published: September, 2008
Number of pages: 270
Rating: 5 out of 5
From the moment she got off the plane, we both sensed a fundamental change in our relationship. Like a bottle of wine that only comes into its best after it's had time to breathe, our love was ready to drink.
For the next ten days, we barely spent a minute apart. And in the quiet times, almost without discussing it, we became aware that this part of our lives was coming to a close. We would return to Paris, set up a home, marry, have children.
Within three weeks, to the astonishment of my friends, I'd emptied my apartment, disposed of my possessions, and booked a flight to Paris, a city where I'd never lived, in a country where I knew nobody, and whose language I couldn't speak. I was fifty, Marie-Dominique ten years younger, and nobody believed it would last a fortnight, if indeed it survived as far as the airport. (p. 111)
I found this book while scouring the shelves at Barnes and Noble for the perfect present to give in the Book Blogger's Holiday Swap. It is a marvelous book which either introduces you to the pleasures of France, or reminds you of how much you've missed them.
John Baxter, an Australian by birth, writes of his marriage to Marie-Dominique and their subsequent move to Paris. This book chronicles the Christmas dinner he plans and prepares for Marie-Do's family, along with insights into the French lifestyle and "ideologie". I loved it.
How does an Australian cook for the very particular French? Can you imagine two cuisines more diverse?
In hell, it's been said, the drivers are Italian and the police French, while the lovers, and worse the cooks are English. The Australia of my childhood still thought of itself as an outpost of the British Empire, and ate accordingly. Scandalously for a country abounding in succulent fish and seafood, fresh greens and salads, in mangos, papayas,, and pineapples, Australian cuisine comprised hot dogs and meat pies, fried fish and chips, overcooked roasts, soggy vegetables, and canned fruit with canned cream." (p. 7)
Not so the French. The chapters in this book discuss the careful selection of just the right wine, the perfect cheese, the proper meat for the main course, the freshest oysters for the beginning, and of course, the bread:
It's customary to praise French bread. Even more than cheese and wine, bread represents something central to the French personality. One of the greatest compliments is to say of someone, "He is like good bread." To deny the people bread or undermine its worth is to strike at the very heart of the nation. (. 162)
Of course, Christmas is not composed only of the food which one consumes. Christmas is filled with the location of where we spend it, and with whom. I'm unable to celebrate Christmas in some of my favorite places: the childhood home in which I grew up has been sold, the apartment in Germany where I prepared my first turkey was leased to someone else twenty years ago. Home is what we make of where we are now, and one is all the more fortunate if it is familiar:
Proust was right. Any house or garden or town existed only as the sum of the feelings experienced there. It was remembering history and maintaining tradition that kept the material world alive. (p. 219)
The meal comes together beautifully at the conclusion of the book: the roast pig with its cracklings and Cajun spices, which horrified one of the cousins until she learned that Cajun people have their roots in French ancestors, were consumed with the perfect wine and the accompaniment of roasted potatoes, carrot pudding, stuffing, apple compote, and fruits brulee. It is enough to make me anticipate the upcoming holiday feasts with greater longing than I already feel.
Baxter reminds us of feasts mentioned throughout the course of literature and history: Isak Dinesen's Babette's Feast is one. But, there is the other, more sacred in my mind:
A ritual? That most of all. There was enough religion in me to see all meals as sacramental, and this one especially. Religion was full of food: bread and wine, fish and fowl, flesh and blood. When Christ felt his time on earth was coming to an end, he summoned his disciples not to a sermon but to a supper. (p. 258)
This book offers a fresh look at food, at love, at Christmas and family, but most of all at Paris. C'est merveilleux.
Or couse, I couldn't write a post about another country without including "my" Italy. If there's one new Christmas album you buy this year, buy this. I can't even describe how fantastic it is. In every way.

I looked at this book yesterday and now I regret not buying it! Cooking a traditional American holiday meal was quite a challenge for me when we lived in France. (I'll have to pick this up when I go shopping for the holiday swap!)
ReplyDeleteHi Meredith :D
ReplyDeleteI have celebrated many a French Christmas in France and keep some of my most cherished memories from that period of my life.
Thank-you for this great review and a book I will be looking for at my bookstore.
Wishing you a great week and a nice Thanksgiving to you and those you love,
xoxox
Sylvie Madeleine
This book sounds wonderful! I will have to pick up a copy...hmmm maybe my secret Santa would like a copy of this... And I also picked up Andrea Bocelli's Christmas album! It is simply a feast for the ears!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the tip. Sounds like a foodie bibliophile delight. I'm reading feast, Dineson and Proust and wondering how quickly I can sneak out to the bookstore.... Hmmm. Happy reading!
ReplyDeleteIt was difficult for me, too, partly because I was a new bride, but also because the oven was in Centigrade not Fahrenheit! This is a delightful book to add to your collection if you know France at all, which it appears you do having lived there.
ReplyDeleteSo you know how great Bocelli's album is, too! I'm so glad you agree!
ReplyDeleteSylvie, I was thinking of you while reading this fabulous book. There are bits of French scattered throughout, of which I can read a little, but I imagine you'd adore. France has such an elegant way of living, and in my opinion, far less emphasis on things. I love that.
ReplyDeleteNot only foodie, but "armchair traveler" as well. Baxter is such a good writer he really takes us to Paris in these pages. (I've added you to my links, by the way, because your blog is so lovely.)
ReplyDeleteAhhh, a Christmas in France? I would probably think I'd died and gone to heaven. I didn't read Babette's Feast, but I saw the movie and I loved it. Cooking heals the soul.
ReplyDeleteoops, that was me!
ReplyDeleteI really like the cover of that book!
ReplyDeleteI read this post on my iPhone earlier today and this book sounded so wonderful that I looked for it at my own B&N when I went there today...and do you know that they didn't have it :( What I did find though was a gorgeous copy of Truman Capote's A Christmas Memory! So I scooped that up :) Can't wait to read that one. I still must get my hands on this one though!! I'm dying to read it after your review. You make me salivate for books Bellezza!
ReplyDeleteI knew it was you. ;)
ReplyDeleteSandy, I'd just die to have Christmas in Europe, period! You probably know what that's like from Poland. I've only seen Christmas in Germany and Switzerland, myself.
ReplyDeleteIsn't it funny that different stores of the same name carry such different books? I get so mad when that happens I say real loudly, "Well, I guess I'll just order it from amazon.com." It's the nasty, passive-aggressive side of me that can't get what she wants. I think I learn it from my third graders, or, maybe my father. ;)
ReplyDeleteI wonder what Truman Capote remembers of Christmas?! That's rather a scary thought. You'll have to let me know when you finish it. And, how does one read from one's iPhone? I'm very impressed, Inspector Gadget.
Looks like a great read and the perfect find for your swap. Love the cover, it's so festive. Thanks for the excerpts!
ReplyDeleteGreat review of a truly delicious sounding book. Christmas in Paris--heck, anything in Paris! *swoon* Oh well; that's what books are for, right?
ReplyDeleteCool! I requested this one for review a while back, but I wasn't lucky enough to receive a copy. I'm glad you loved it. It looks marvelous.
ReplyDeleteMaybe this Christmas it'll appear, Andi. I hope so, for your sake.
ReplyDeleteRight! I love living through my books' eyes. They take me places I long to go, or, revisit.
ReplyDeleteI've been enjoying this Bocelli cd at work. It's one of our in-store plays for December. I hear it at least 2-3 times during my 8-hour shift. :)
ReplyDeleteUh oh, it doesn't sound like it'll be a winner for you! Too much of a good thing and all that...I remember working at Marshall Field's, and the soundtracks would repeat and repeat and repeat until I thought I'd go crazy. Even worse, they were that Muzak crap!
ReplyDeleteOh, I don't know. I've been listening to Michael Buble and Pink Martini for the past few weeks (at work) and am lovin' them so much, I plan to get the albums. (Guess I should say cds, huh?)
ReplyDeleteI have to pick up my class from PE now, but I wish we could keep chatting! XO
ReplyDeleteBeautiful review though lots of spoilers. Still, I enjoyed it a lot. I can't express my delight in words that could equal yours!
ReplyDelete